1. Compare the actual roles, not just the job titles
Articles 17 and 29 of the PRC Labor Contract Law make work content a mandatory contract term and require performance of agreed obligations. Read the signed contract, amendments, incorporated job description and actual assignments together. Record the present tasks, decision-making authority, reporting line, team responsibilities and required skills; then identify exactly what the proposed role removes or adds. A new title with substantially unchanged work differs from replacing a specialist function with unrelated duties.
Confirm whether this is a temporary assignment or a lasting reassignment. Keep the same-employer role decision separate from any change of legal employer, workplace or working hours. Identify the China entity’s authorized decision-maker and the genuine operational need. A group-level approval is supporting business evidence, not the employee’s consent or a substitute for the contractual analysis.
2. Establish the legal basis for this particular reassignment
Where agreed terms are being changed, Article 35 provides for mutual agreement in writing, with each party retaining a copy. Whether an instruction is instead a reasonable exercise of authority within the existing arrangement requires examination of the clause, actual work and applicable local approach. A broad “business needs” clause is not unlimited discretion. An employee handbook also cannot automatically displace contractual promises: Article 50 of SPC Interpretation (I) addresses conflicts between internal rules and collective or individual contracts.
Beijing’s 2024 labor-dispute Q&A, Question 59, distinguishes several situations. A contractual adjustment clause still requires proof of changed operational circumstances and reasonable reassignment. Where the role is unspecified or unclear, legitimate operational reasons, the employee’s competence and no adverse change in pay or other working conditions are relevant. Where the role is clearly agreed but adjustment is not, a unilateral change outside Article 40 situations is treated as a breach. This is Beijing guidance, not an automatic nationwide exemption; assess the rules applicable to the actual work location.
3. Test the claim that the employee is no worse off
Compare the whole package: fixed pay, commission opportunities, bonus eligibility and targets, allowances, benefits, hours and work-related costs. Keeping base salary unchanged while removing the customer portfolio that generates commission may materially affect the arrangement. Also check rank, substantive responsibility, qualifications, health and safety requirements, and whether the employee can realistically perform the new tasks. Record the comparison rather than relying on a payroll total alone.
Explain why this employee and this role were selected, what alternatives were considered, and what training or transition support will be provided. Do not use an empty, humiliating or deliberately unachievable assignment to induce resignation. A transition assessment must not be presented as a second statutory probation period: Article 19 permits only one probation agreement between the same employer and employee. If inability to perform is the real concern, preserve the relevant assessment and support records instead of inventing a reorganization rationale.
4. Separate an objection from a disciplinary finding
Ask the employee to identify the disputed duties and practical constraints, and respond to those points before escalating. A signature acknowledging receipt is not necessarily acceptance. Record where and how the employee is expected to work during review, keep access and instructions consistent, and distinguish continued work in the existing role from failure to attend at all. Refusal of an unsupported reassignment does not automatically establish resignation or serious misconduct.
Any dismissal requires its own lawful ground and procedure. Article 39(2) requires serious violation of the employer’s rules; a refusal label alone is insufficient. The inability-to-perform route in Article 40(2) requires that the employee remains unable after training or reassignment; Article 42 protections and the applicable notice, compensation and union procedures must also be checked. Interpretation (I), Article 44 places the burden on the employer in disputes arising from dismissal decisions. Do not issue a dismissal while the authority for the underlying instruction remains unresolved.
5. Document the agreed change and the implementation file
If agreement is reached, record the duties, reporting line, pay components, targets, effective date, duration and any return arrangements, and provide each party with the signed text. Article 43 of Interpretation (I) addresses an agreed oral amendment performed for more than one month whose contents violate neither laws and administrative regulations nor public order and good morals: lack of writing alone does not invalidate it. It is not permission to treat one month’s silence as automatic consent; preserve agreement, performance and objections.
Prepare the contract and adjustment clause, old and new job descriptions, organization records, business rationale, full remuneration comparison, capability and training material, employee responses and proposed notices. The review should produce a concrete choice: proceed within supported existing authority, agree a revised role, or reconsider the proposal. For an initial consultation, identify the employing entity, work city, main duty changes and proposed date; arrange a secure channel before providing personnel records.
Legal sources
Official sources · Checked 2026-11-19. Translations are for reference and are not official legal texts.
- PRC Labor Contract Law (2012 amendment) ↗
Articles 4, 17, 19, 26, 29–30, 35 and 39–47: agreed work, amendments, probation and dismissal safeguards.
- SPC Interpretation (I) on Labor Disputes, Fa Shi [2020] No. 26 ↗
Articles 43–44 and 50: oral amendments, dismissal evidence and conflicts between rules and contracts.
- Beijing High Court and Labor Arbitration Commission: Labor Dispute Q&A (I), Jing Gao Fa Fa [2024] No. 534 ↗
Question 59: Beijing guidance distinguishing contractual authority, unspecified roles and clearly agreed roles.
General information about mainland China. The facts, applicable dates and local rules require individual review.
Review the role change before issuing instructions
Compare the old and new duties, contractual authority and employee impact before committing to reassignment or disciplinary action.
Discuss your matter ↗